Old Time Bagels

I was just a passed by yesterday for a quick b’fast and surprisingly enjoyed. I had a plain butter bagel and smaller side compare to one I usually have in the City. But this bagel was so high graded and good amount of tasty butter on it. I also want to say my coffee with milk was great and the people there so good. Small place and not cheap bagel place but they have done such a great breakfast for me.

Hey everyone, so I have visited this bagel shop several times and they do not disappoint! Typically I order a Turkey sausage, egg, & cheese-salt, pepper, with pure honey. My order is always fresh (especially the meat) and cooked to order. Inside of the shop it is clean, filled with live, fun, and welcoming decor! The owners are very pleasant, friendly, and thorough. Definitely would recommend this establishment.

Breakfast while working Medic Unit #1201 on March 28th, 2025... Stopped by at Old Time Bagels on Hwy 35, Hazlet NJ. This is the second day of 2 shifts before a 3 Day Weekend Off and my choose is Bacon, Eggs, Cheese, Tomato Slices, Jalapeno Slices seasoned with SPK between toasted Hard Roll to contain the deliciousness!!! This Family Owned Business has been in existence for as long as I can remember and continues to prepare a very tasty sandwich...

Visiting from Florida and stopped in to Old Time Bagels. The owners, food, prices and atmosphere was terrific. Will definitely be back before heading home and definitely recommend visiting if you haven't already. Thank you Old Time Bagels for the great experience!

Just because it’s shaped like a bagel doesn’t make it a bagel. I am there every Wednesday morning where I buy 8 bagels. From the glass you can see the giant vat in the back where they ACTUALLY boil their bagels which is the correct way to make a bagel and not just round dough in the shape of a bagel. These bagels are the best bagels I’ve ever had in New Jersey since moving from New York. The woman behind the counter is always so nice. Their bagels for the quality are well priced. I have plenty of bagel spots around where I live but I drive a few extra miles to this place.