Old Scratch Pizza

I visited Old Scratch Pizza for the first time today and was really excited to try it because I had heard good things about the place. Unfortunately, my experience was disappointing. I ordered the Scratch Garlic Bread and the Old Scratch Pizza. The garlic bread was extremely salty — so much so that we could barely eat it. It honestly felt overwhelming and unpleasant. The pizza itself also did not taste good and did not meet the expectations I had before visiting. Since this was my first visit, I was hoping for a great experience, but sadly it didn’t turn out that way. I hope the restaurant can review the seasoning and overall quality so future customers can have a better experience.

This is my go to place for my teenager and myself. The music is great, the atmosphere open, and the pizza divine. Do not come here if you're looking for a NY Style pizza - much more ITALIAN! Fresh basil and motzrella on the "Margherita". The "Angry Bee-Keeper" adds a bit of heat with the hot honey. The hummus the best I've had in the area. Prices are very reasonable.

First time visit, had a fantastic experience. Service was quick, helpful, and friendly. Restaurant was clean, open, and overall welcoming. Definitely coming back. Great pizza.

I've been coming to Old Scratch, primarily the Centerville location, for about 6 years now, probably at least 7-8 visits year. I've signed up for their rewards program. Normally very happy with the service, quality of food, atmosphere. Last visit, not so. I went for a late lunch during the week, so not busy at all. Ordered at the counter at 1:05 pm, was order #43. Sat down, opened up my laptop to work while I waited. Around 1:33 pm, realized I still had no pizza, while orders #55 and above were having theirs delivered to the table. Approached staff, who went to check with the kitchen - they must have somehow just completely missed my order, or maybe marked it complete after bringing out my side salad, without ever making the pizza. Finally received mine at 1:37 pm, and then had to rush ea

Very large tables to seat large families expanded open dining area . I would appreciate padding on the seating areas. Three Wood fired oven, creates a warm atmosphere. The pizza and salad were exceptional. This is my first time here, and I highly recommend this pizza place.