OddFellows Ice Cream Co.

✨first visit to OddFellows Ice Cream at the Wiregrass Shops. Pros: Location Unique Flavors Open Late Discount when purchasing with cash Vegan flavors and To Go Tubs I tried the Black Sesame Cookies and Cream on a chocolate waffle cone. They play great music and my server Kylie is a gem. She was very patient and hospitable while I took my time deciding which flavor to try. She went above and beyond and I am inspired to return because of her excellent customer service. ✨

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ OddFellows in the Tampa/Wesley Chapel area is hands-down the best ice cream spot around. From the moment you walk in, it’s a treat — but what truly made our visit extra sweet (pun fully intended 😉) was Aadi. Aadi went above and beyond with such genuine kindness, patience, and enthusiasm. He made thoughtful recommendations, let us sample flavors, and somehow made the whole experience feel personal and fun.. not rushed at all. You can tell he truly enjoys what he does, and that energy makes a huge difference. The ice cream itself is incredible; rich, creative flavors and top-tier quality, BUT the customer service took it to the next level. If you’re looking for amazing ice cream and an experience that leaves you smiling, OddFellows (and Aadi!) is the place to go. We’ll definitely be ba

Arrr, gather ‘round me hearties and lend an ear, for I’ve just dropped anchor at a most wondrous port o’ frozen treasure — Oddfellows Ice Cream Co. in Wesley Chapel, and by the beard o’ Poseidon, it be a place fit for kings, sailors, and sugar-cravin’ rogues alike! 🍨⚓️ The moment I crossed the threshold, I was greeted by a fair lass named Olivia, who handed me me loot — a mighty double scoop o’ Vanilla Bean so rich and creamy it near made me forget me own name. The flavor hit like a siren’s song on a calm sea — smooth, sweet, and speckled with vanilla bits finer than the sand on Tortuga’s shores. Aye, it were so good I nearly proposed to the cup. The place itself be a feast for the eyes — red-and-white stripes like a captain’s finest flag, and walls lined with mirrors and cheeky monkey p

Great spot, delicious ice cream, and friendly staff. Happy to see a quality ice cream shop with options for everyone (regular, vegan, dairy-free, soy-free, gluten-free, etc). Would definitely recommend if you are looking for a delicious treat. They even have both indoor & outdoor seating (plus bathrooms) if you want to stay and enjoy!

i’ve been waiting for the opening of this ice cream shop for a little bit ! the atmosphere is super fun and quirky which i love, the variety of different flavors is so nice, and as someone who has lactose intolerance it’s hard to find a good shop with dairy free options that still has the creamy texture and taste of regular dairy ice cream. the owner was super sweet ! will be coming and may even be a regular lol.