Nicolo's Pizzeria

I just Ordered and just received it. It came burnt and there was practically no cheese or sauce on my Chicken Parmesan sandwich. I always pick up never have it delivered. Just everyone beware if you have it delivered open what you buy. They know most likely know you aren’t going to send it back. Very disappointed because I always go there and never had a problem. The staff is always nice and the food is good. But don’t have it delivered unless you Look before they leave.

This was some really good pizza, like really good pizza. Perfect crisp, with a great amount of cheese to sauce ratio. Nice old school feel to the shop, brought me back to HS. They also have ZEPPOLES which was an awesome surprise. They were light, fluffy and fresh. Pretty decent customer service as well. Will def return next time I'm in the area.

Great personnel, delicious pizza, and the finest cheesesteak in Old Bridge, hands down. Pizza is consistently delicious and well-served.

After hearing about this place through many people, I decided to try it tonight .The definition of pizza 🙏🏻 fantastic plain slice! Emerged as a new favorite place for me.The zeppoles served on Fridays were a great dessert to follow! Really enjoyed it ! Thank you Joe for the hospitality, will be back🙏🏻

Fantastic pizza, great staff and the cheesesteak is the best one in Old Bridge hands down. Pizza is always consistent and great service