Nick's Pizza

First time here & I'll definitely be back!😋 I was here alone & got a medium pepperoni, sausage & mushrooms. So hearty & delicious. 6 sit down booths, or take it to go. And dont forget to let it cool a little.

I've been eating Nick's pizza my whole life and my parents have longer than that. Over the last year, or so, the trays of pizza have been consistently overcooked. We ask to have it cooked on the lighter side, but it's always too dark and the crust is burned. Both of the trays we ordered tonight looked like this. I'd even be willing to take it uncooked and bake it at home for the perfectly golden crust that Nick himself used to bake.

OMG if you miss going to Nick's you missed the best pizza ever. We were in Newburyport for just a few days and stopped one night. We all 4 got the individual pizza everyone came out perfect. Quaint little place . Friendly people. Excellent crust, great sauce and many toppings to choose from. We are from St. Louis have some very good pizza but Nick's out did us with their pizza. You have stop in you won't be disappointed.

Hands down the best pizza in Newburyport. I have no idea how they do it, but it might be the best cheese pizza I've ever had in my life. So much flavor in every bite. Parking can be rough, but it is well worth it. Hop up on the curb in front and everyone in town knows to give some space as they drive by.

Doesn’t know what gluten free is. Got a pizza gluten free and added chicken. They breaded the chicken. Seriously? Luckily it was only on half the pizza so I took the other half just being cheese because I was starving. He said he was only going to give me half my money back. Terrible hospitality.