Nick Charlap’s Ice Cream

Would give 0 if I could. I never leave Google reviews but here I am. I came today, Sunday at around 7 pm. There was no line, nothing. I was standing at the window for a bit, one girl came from the back and took care of me, and was very kind and polite while taking my order. the other two with dark hair didn't seem to be very amused. I got my ice cream and waited about 15 minutes for my food, even though I ordered one thing and was the only person there. The two with darker hair seemed to be the ones preparing the food. I mean I get it was a slow day so I understand, but the food that I received was WAY overcooked and just falling apart... I ended up throwing out the food and wasn't going to bother asking for them to remake it because when the one dark haired girl in the grayish/white hande

I have been here twice and both times were pretty good. The first time I ordered a twist in a cone and I loved it. The second time I got a strawberry sundae and it was pretty good. My boyfriend ordered a buttercrunch sundae and said the ice cream seemed a bit freezer burnt. Staff is friendly. I will go back again.

My husband and I just went there for ice cream. Charlap's is one of my husband's favorite places for ice cream. Today he got Peanut Butterfudge and I got Vanilla with peanut butter swirl and chocolate chips frozen yogurt. Both were delicious! I highly recommend this family owned business

Don't understand why this place doesn't have long lines like Andersen's. The ice cream is at least as good. Maybe better. So that was my review. The only flavor I've ever gotten has been buttercrunch. A few days ago I got some and it was totally different and really lousy. Bad enough so I would go back to Andersen's. I hope they go back to what that had. It tasted like really cheap iced cream

Daughter & I took the kids there for lunch today. Used to go when it was Reeds. Ordered 5 hot dogs 2 fries & 5 small drinks. $46.00 dollars later, what a rip! Stingy with everything! I guess we were lucky we got ice in our drinks! And not learning my lesson yet I got everyone a baby size twist cone ! It wasn’t even half a twist 😂😂I couldn’t believe it they were 3.15 each. I’m not kidding when I say half a twist either. This is probably the most stingiest place right down to everything including condiments on your food! Do not waster your hard earned money!! Total cost today 63.00 & change! Shame on you charlaps!!!