Newtown Square Pizza

I rarely write reviews, but this was truly awful. It was the worst pizza I’ve ever had. The whole thing looked like it was prefabricated and shipped frozen to the store. I ordered a large margarita (actually spelled that way on the menu) with extra basil. The premade crust was the worst part—stiff, flat, and bland. The cheese was barely melted and solidified into solid discs that fell off when you took a bite. The only thing “extra” about the basil was the price, $2.50 for the few pieces you see in the photo. I can’t believe they charged $23.84 for this thing. I will never go back. Outrageous!

Ordered a cheesesteak with provolone n fried onions. It wasn’t bad at first. Until I chewed on something hard in my bite. I spit out what was clearly a meat bone shard. I get things like that happen. It was the first time I’ve ever encountered a bone in a cheesesteak and it was the last time I’ll be ordering from there.

The guy up front with that warrior cut and those dreamy freckles are honestly the only reason I go to this place… i come in everyday after work to see him and honestly don’t have the courage to hit on him yet but I really hope this gets his attention! (P.S. if you’re seeing this dino… next time I come in for my usual let’s talk about future plans.)

Never ordering from here again. My order was 19.60 and was paying cash. The delivery driver conveniently didn't have change, so I was forced to give a 10-dollar tip. He never asked if I wanted him to come back with change or not. On top of that the pasta is beyond over cooked; I get it that it's not an Italian spot, but this was nasty.... straight to the trash smh! Their lack of response to google reviews shows how little they care!

The food is always good but the service behind the counter or the ones who answer the phone are awful. My family usually order from here every Friday but after today I don’t think we will be using them ever again. I asked for a hamburger medium and the kid on the phone had no clue what I was talking about. I asked to speak to a manager and they just gave the phone to another kid, I asked to speak to the manager from him and they gave me an older sounding kid. All I wanted to do was make sure the order was correct since the last kid I talked to sounded like his mind was blown and thankfully I asked cause, the pepperoni Stromboli I ordered some how was a pepperoni cheese steak. Then the manager was nice and said I would get a $10 discount for the confusion told me the total and it was more t