New York Gyro Central Ave

My "chicken korma" was four chunks of grey mystery meat literally swimming in two cups of old fryer oil. The only thing that could have come close to resembling korma were the crusty bits of debris from foods past stuck to the bottom of the takeout tin. Later found out the meat was in fact lamb which I do not consume for religious reasons. Perhaps thankfully I only was able to eat two bites before giving up and tossing most of my meal. Still the fact that a meat was substituted without my knowledge nor consent was very upsetting. Instead of the dried fruit naan for which I paid more I was given plain naan that was somehow overly chewy and stale at the same time. I took a single bite of gulab jamun before giving up on that as well when it tasted almost the same as the "chicken korma" I

It’s a tradition for me to try out new spots for my birthday so I went here two years ago and the food is SO good. Here is where you’ll get the most authentic food you can find, the flavors are bold and strong. It’s so delicious with the naan. Definitely coming back here sometime soon, just thinking about it makes my mouth water haha

Yoooo, THIS is IT. Literally, just go here. Solid all around. Hearing this from a tried and tested foodie. And for to go? Why would you not? Stop reading reviews. Go.

Went in for the first time in a few years, and it does seem like ownership has changed or just that there’s been a big update to the menu! Ordered butter chicken and swapped the bread for rice, and then got the fish and fries. Also got some mango lassi. We waited maybe 10 minutes for our food, but it was pretty busy and there were some large groups doing takeout at the same time. Overall, we really enjoyed the food! The butter chicken and rice reminded me of when my friend made me butter chicken from scratch, and I really enjoyed it! The rice was fluffy and flavorful, too. The fish was not what we expected - the picture on the menu I feel makes it look more “plain” but it had a really nice seasoning on it. Fries could have been more salty, but we liked them! The mango lassi wasn’t my fav

“NY Gyro is an amazing place to eat! The quality and quantity of the food are outstanding, and everything is 100% halal, which is also great for Muslim customers. The staff is incredibly friendly, respectful, and always serves with care, making each visit enjoyable. I’ve been here many times, and the consistency in their service and food is impressive. Whether you’re looking for delicious flavors or a welcoming atmosphere, this restaurant is a must-visit. Highly recommended!”