My Tomato Pie

Amherst, NY · Italian restaurant

Rating
4.4/5
★★★★☆ 4.4
Reviews
20
Rank in Amherst
#28
of 150 restaurants
City Percentile
75%
rating percentile
Address
My Tomato Pie, 3055 Niagara Falls Blvd, Amherst, NY 14228
Phone
(716) 838-0969
Website
mytomatopie.com
Status
Closes soon · 10 PM · Opens 11 AM Sat

My Tomato Pie is a restaurant located in Amherst, NY. It is one of 150 restaurants listed in Amherst. Its 4.4-star rating is above the Amherst city average of 4.1 stars. There are 10 photos associated with this location.

About My Tomato Pie

One of Buffalo's most unique pizza restaurants. Along with our large bar, we offer a private banquet room and full serve catering. The menu includes homemade soups, salad dressings, delicious gourmet pizzas, pastas, and sandwiches served on homemade... More

Hours

Friday11 AM–10 PM

Customer Reviews

★★★★★ 5.0 Mark · Nov 2025

We have a great time here for my Grandpas Birthday! Great service restaurant and food definitely suggest this place!

★★★★☆ 4.0 Suparna Banerjee · Jun 2025

Ordered take out from her while visiting Niagara . It was very close to our Airbnb. Viagarro Pizza-5/5 ( nice veg fresh, dough was fresh and so was the cheese) would have loved more veggies on them. Carissa Pizza- 4/5.Chicken Pizza dough was also very fresh and the cheese was really good. Chicken protein was good. Would had loved more veggies. Definitely worth visiting.

★☆☆☆☆ 1.0 Maria C · Jan 2026

pizza is good, but we ordered a pizza with half anchovies because I like them, my partner can't stand them. never seen a pizza prepared with the anchovies completely under the cheese, totally hidden. a complete mystery which pieces had them or not. his first bite, he bit into one and just gave up eating altogether at that point. really not a great way to serve a pizza, didn't think this was rocket science... edit: this response is garbage. I have been making pizzas for years, I've worked for restaurants that make pizzas, I order many. anchovies go on top. they never disintegrate. you're the only people making them this way and it's absurd. now you get one star instead of two.

★★★★★ 5.0 David N · Feb 2026

A unique name for a wonderful restaurant. Love it. Extensive menu with a great variety. Service was very good. Love the atmosphere, feels very comfortable. Don't pass this place up, you'll miss something great.

★★★★★ 5.0 Shay W · Feb 2026

Ordered take out personal Pie...drove 10 miles...First time customer. Pleasantly surprised! Delicious fresh dough and fresh ingredients and great cheese.

Accessibility & Amenities

✓ Wheelchair Accessible Entrance ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Restroom ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Seating

Services

Italian restaurantAmerican restaurantBanquet hallPizza restaurantRestaurant

Top Restaurants in Amherst

NameRatingReviews
NEVERLAND CAFÉ★★★★★ 5.020 reviews
Anchi A La Carte★★★★★ 4.920 reviews
95 Nutrition Headquarters★★★★★ 4.820 reviews
Ranchos Tacos★★★★★ 4.820 reviews
Sisters and Son's Pizzeria and Deli★★★★★ 4.720 reviews
Hawaiian BBQ Food Truck & Catering★★★★★ 4.720 reviews
Natalie's Mediterranean Eatery★★★★★ 4.720 reviews
Vin-Chet Bakery★★★★★ 4.720 reviews
K-BBQ & Hot Pot★★★★★ 4.720 reviews
Artusi★★★★★ 4.720 reviews

This listing is informational. Contact the business directly to verify credentials, services, and availability.