Mr. Pizza

Came in for some slices, they had pepperoni and cheese Sicilian slices. Not in a heated rotating box just sitting there. They slapped the two slices on a plate and sent me off. No offer of warm up, pieces most certainly not fresh. They were fine but damn don't come in hungry wanting some hot slices. Everything smelled good, very small place, had to wait 5 mins to be waited on. Just wanted some warmed up za not some cold cheese. Slices weren't even good

If you’re looking for authentic Sicilian pizza, look no further. The ingredients—dough and sauce included—are all freshly made. The sauce is zesty and rich, just as it should be, and the crust was cooked to perfection. Pricing is very reasonable: two slices and a bottle of Pepsi (though I wish they carried Coke products) came to just $7.75. Definitely worth trying. 3.5 stars ⭐️

Update 3-28-24 went here again today. Ordered hot wings with Louisiana sauce and a meatball sub. The sauce on the wings was good. It had a underlying vinegary taste with a kick. Only down fall was the wings were not crispy . Next time I will ask for them crispy. My boyfriend liked the meat ball sub. The roll was homemade. The bread absorbed most of the sauce on the sub. Next time we will ask go a side of sauce with the sub. Everything tasted yummy. Will definitely be back ........The restaurant itself definitely has a lack of atmosphere.It's a takeout place. They don't have anywhere to eat inside. They did have a picknick table outside though. They also sell pizza by the slice.The pepperoni pizza we ordered was pretty good. We ordered the Sicilian.I don't normally care for pizza crust. I l

We love the antipasto salad at Mr. Pizza. Fresh ingredients and comes with their delicious dressing & Italian bread. Definitely on the top of our list for quick take out.

Walked in the front door and the place is so dirty and cramped, I wanted to just leave. It's tiny and awkward so I felt obligated to order something. Got a few slices of pizza to go. Took 1 bite and threw it out. Probably been sitting in their little warming oven for hours. Everything about the place looks and feels filthy, including the fully visible kitchen. I can't figure out how this place has 4+ stars, in NY, in a town with at least 5 MUCH better pizza places. I felt gross just walking in the front door.