Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Peoria, AZ

Mr. Pickles -First visit -Ordered online for pick up -online pick up area was behind the counter, so we had to wait for the five people in front of us in line to order to get our food that was sitting there ready to go -Order was 100% correct and done on time -10% tip was automatically included and not shown until payment went through *Macaroni salad- decent, not amazing, not offensive, wouldn't need it in the future *Horseradish mayo, $0.99 for 1.5 oz in a 4 oz container is not happiness, but the product itself was my favorite thing in the entire order *Au Jus- while I don't need it be to hot, it was cold, decent flavor, but not awesome. While adequately wrapped, still leaked *Ranch, liquidy, very light in flavor, good as a salad ranch, however, paying $0.99 for easily 1.5oz in a 4 oz

I love Mr pickles. They were my go to sandwich place in Scottsdale but this location, I’m not sure what is happening. I’ve ordered maybe 6 times from this location and 3 of those times my sandwich was incorrect like today. I ordered a my deli where you build your own sandwich. I only wanted turkey and lettuce. And of course I get home and there is a surprise piece of bacon in it. Thank goodness I’m not Jewish or Muslim. And it also had lackluster amount of turkey when I’m paying almost $10 for a sandwich. I want to be a repeat customer but I’m getting tired of careless mistake.

Heard good things so I was excited to try Mr, Pickles. Ordered online and picked up, which was a fine experience and quick and easy process. Order was accurate and we ordered a Kickin Chicken and Listen Linda. Cookies that came with the meal were soft, and great! The ingredients and overall sub taste was excellent, tasted fresh and lots of flavor. The bad... The top bread of the Kickin Chicken was rock hard, without any exaggeration. I'm talking unable to bend or bite without excessive force. Bread makes the sandwich, so this ruined the overall experience for me. The Listen Linda was less solid metal feel, and a bit softer but was still described by my wife as too hard. I'm all about artesian, fancy breads, but this shop missed the mark by a mile.

Finally!! Just what was needed, an AMAZINGLY good sandwich shop! Great choices, excellent quality and amount of proteins on each sammie! Keep it up! Staying consistent will be what’s needed in 85383!

Exceptionally average food, while maintaining high prices and low value. $16 for a tiny little sandwich that takes almost 20m to make. I can’t in good faith eat here knowing I could get a massive, custom, handcrafted, delicious sandwich stacked an inch high with boars head meat across the street at sprouts for $12. At least the cookie was free.