Missy Kay's Sweet Shoppe

Great new addition to Windsor! Family-owned, reasonable prices, impressive selection. Old school and new school candy, stickers, keychains, plushies, toys, Colorado honey, local-made beef sticks, sodas and drinks of all kinds, blind boxes and other novelties, and even a pinball machine at the back! Owners stated that they'll be adding fresh, in-house cookies to their offerings soon, too. Looking forward to seeing this shop grow!

Super cute shop in downtown Windsor. Found some candy we haven’t seen in years, loved the cookies and will be back for some small gifts and stoking stuffers. Definitely recommend!

Great selection, wonderful, nostalgic candies…even have Lemonheads and Bit O Honey! There are lots of things to smile, chuckle, and remember fondly…however not a fan of the fact that they sell candy cigarettes and their prices do seem to be on the high end. Not sure I’ll be back, but it was fun to stop by, if for nothing else than to peruse the selections. ‘Definitely a lot of effort put into having great variety and to enable a walk down memory lane to revisit the candies you had as a kid!

Such a fun shop with tons of nostalgic candy, unique sodas, and even Paleta Payaso and Pelón which are hard to find. They also have toys and unique sodas that make perfect decorations or gifts for so many occasions. A great spot to explore and pick up something sweet for yourself or to share!

Carmels were good, unfortunately all the bagged candy we purchased seemed old, we looked at the dates and they were both going to expire this month. For the prices you would expect a fresher purchase... they didnt taste or eat that great being so old!