Mille Luci Pizzeria

Wow what a great experience! This pizza was delicious! We ordered vodka, margarita and Snow White! Each was delicious! We go to alot of pizza spots and this one is one we will definitely come back to. The ingredients were fresh and straight from Italy as the owner shared and showed us. We also had the Joe’s Special Dessert and it was the perfect ending to our meal. The waiter Lucas was friendly and made our time a great one. Joseph the owner came and spoke to us welcoming us.

This authentic Italian restaurant and wine bar in New City is truly a gem. From the moment you walk in, you can feel that it’s a family-owned business built on love, pride, and genuine hospitality. The owner is incredibly warm and attentive, making every guest feel like part of the family. You can tell how much heart and passion goes into every detail — from the food to the service to the cozy atmosphere. The pizzas are phenomenal — perfectly light, airy, and beautifully crisp with that authentic Italian texture that doesn’t leave you feeling heavy. Every bite tastes fresh and thoughtfully crafted. The garlic zeppoles are hands down the best bite-sized indulgence — golden, fluffy, and absolutely addictive when paired with their rich, flavorful marinara sauce (you’ll definitely want extra!)

Great food! The flour is so delicate that it didn’t make me bloated. I loved it so much the music taste was so good and they played some Ella Fitzgerald and Frank Sinatra! The service was excellent and there so welcoming towards the customers! I recommend it a lot

Some of the best pizza I’ve had! I can taste the freshness , and the basil was a great touch . I do wish the edges weren’t as burnt, & also that they made it clear they don’t accept cash when I placed my order, but it worked out. Definitely a new favorite!

Met a friend here for dinner for the first time and it did not disappoint. Another friend had highly recommended the hot honey pizza and we also ordered the prosciutto & burratta pizza. They were amazing! Highly recommend! The wine list is also extensive. For dessert I had the pistachio cake & my friend had the cannoli… the perfect sweet but light end to the meal. The service was friendly, and I really liked that even though the place was packed, the acoustics were such that it wasn’t noisy or echoey like some places; it provided a warm and cozy atmosphere to enjoy a great meal! Will definitely be back.