Michael's Cafe

We went here for Valentine’s Day and had a really good time. The reason I gave them three stars was our friend ordered a steak well done and it came out (at best) medium rare. For the price ($56 without sides!), I would think they would at least get the steak right. My steak was delicious, I did order mine medium rare, though. The fries are really yummy, mashed potatoes were OK. The crab dip was extremely small for the price, but it was good. Overall, everything was pretty good but overpriced in my opinion. There were also like 10 hostesses sanding at the hostess stand, which was very strange to me. ..

Went with a group of ten including kids. Service was awesome and we were getting our drink orders pretty quick even though the place was packed. Kudos to the bartending staff. I ordered the open faced hot turkey sandwich, while it was tasty, it definitely lacked gravy. I asked our server for extra. I also ordered the tres leches cake, if you’ve had authentic tres leches cake, you’ll be disappointed. Overall, food was good, atmosphere was chill, and the service was great.

We came to Michael’s and always stay at their outdoor patio for the amazing homey decor they have, and the less invasive music compared to the bar and restaurant area, and sit by or closer to the gas fire place. Love it !!!!! Tonight was a rock fish Nicholas special night, what a delicacy ! Paired it with the Terre di Bo Barolo from Italy, and although it was a red, it was a perfect match ! Thank you Gary for making sure we are feeling comfortable and taken care of tonight.

Came on a busy Saturday morning, and got seated immediately! Crazy since they were so busy from all the baby showers. First time here, and was very surprised how elegant and elevated the decor was for a cafe. Our server was Sidney, who was extremely knowledgeable about the menu. Excellent communication through the whole service! Always stopped by to see how the food was and made sure our drinks were filled to the brim. The general manager, Angie, stopped by and recommended that we get the famous crab dip and the cereal French toast for starters. And man was she right, we loved every bite! Overall the service and food were great, so hands down will be back soon.

Seeing as though I typically love Michael’s Cafe, writing this review is disappointing. My partner and I made a reservation for Valentine’s Day. I had been previously gloating about how much I love the restaurant. When we walked in, we were greeted by a slightly irritated hostess to which we understood because of the hectic holiday. We were then sat at a table that was very off to the side next to a door that was continuously being opened, letting in cold air and even blowing out our candle. We sat patiently waiting for someone to notice us and after about 18 minutes of waiting, we were then greeted by our waiter. Unfortunately, I do not remember his name but the first impression was not a great one. Once again, we gave the benefit of the doubt because of the holiday. Our waiter’s attitude