McKinely's Sandwich Shop

The veggie wrap is perfect for a hot day, especially if you're looking for something fresh and filling. I like to try something different each visit and everything I've had so far has been great. The prices are reasonable for the portions and they have a nice variety of options for sandwiches and desserts to choose from. This place fills up quickly around lunch and there is limited seating. Outdoor seating is cute but almost always closed for some reason or another which is a bummer. They are friendly, efficient, and pretty quick considering it's just two of them running the show. This place is so unassuming from the outside but it is my favorite hidden gem in Milton!

We decided to give them a try for lunch today. We had visited once several years ago and we weren't impressed. We both wanted to give their Rebuen a try, but they were out of pastrami. We both chose the club. Probably one of the worst, if not the worst club sandwich that we have had. Just regular bagged bread, not fresh baked, bad mayo, cheddar cheese, not Swiss or provolone, one small piece of tomato. You can get a much better sandwich at Jersey Mike's for lower cost. Not a fan, and won't be back.

Great food and relaxing setting. The sandwiches were delightful. I had the Cuban and the coleslaw and enjoyed it thoroughly.

You will not leave hungry! These sandwiches are stacked with fresh ingredients and delicious! We had the club and turkey panini and had absolutely nothing negative to say about either!

McKinley’s Sandwich Shop is one of those spots that instantly makes you feel at home. The food is always fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. You can taste the homemade quality in every bite. The guys who run the shop are always pleasant, welcoming, and genuinely appreciative of their customers. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick lunch or a relaxing meal, McKinley’s never disappoints.