Mazziotti Bakery

I came in with high hopes and the genuine desire to fall in love with the pastries purveyed by this establishment. Sadly, Mazziotti's does not measure up to any Italian bakery anywhere in Italy. It doesn't even measure up to Italian bakeries and pastry shops in Little Italy in New York City. It's just American stuff with a couple of "Italianato" things thrown in. The level of quality is pretty low, and it's just inundated with huge amounts of sugar, frosting and even the pastry in the eclairs/long johns barely differs from a hot dog bun. I asked if their buttercream was made from real butter, and they insisted that it was, but I suspect based on my years working as a pastry chef that it's a very small proportion of the fat used to make what they call "buttercream". It tastes completely a

This small quaint "mom-pop" bakery is truly a hidden gem! My normal bakery was closed and I needed a cake asap. Mazziotti Bakery definitely took care of me! Customer service was superb! Prices were more than reasonable! The cake was decorated as I requested and it was delicious!

Way better than Oakmont!! Bought a custom birthday cake and a few assortments of cookies. Best I’ve ever had ! This is the place to go ! Don’t waste your money elsewhere. And speaking of money, I felt everything was priced extremely fair !! Great people too ! I’m a lifer now !

Best cakes around ! Always fresh & delicious. Beautifully decorated. Our go to for birthdays and any special occasion!

We ordered a cake and cutting cake for our wedding. Carolyn couldn’t have been nicer and worked with us to get exactly what we wanted. We were looking for floral designed cupcakes and she coordinated the icing colors with fillings (peanut butter and chocolate mousse)! Everything was delicious and beautiful and we had so many compliments!