Mayor's Restaurant

If you’re looking for a great spot in downtown Waukesha, I highly recommend Mayor’s Restaurant. The food is consistently amazing, the atmosphere is fun and welcoming, and the staff is always friendly and attentive. This time I ordered the salmon and it was absolutely incredible—perfectly cooked and topped with their Mayor’s sauce, which is seriously so good. I also tried the Arancini appetizer and wow… so flavorful and cooked just right. And you truly can’t go wrong with the broccoli cheese soup—it’s a must every time. Everything from the service to the food makes it a place we love coming back to. Highly recommend!

Amazing experience! Great variety on the menu. Started our night with mozzarella sticks and Aracini. Our dinners were Chicken Parmigiana, shrimp Alfredo, chicken Alfredo and Diane steak medallions. Fast and friendly service! We cannot wait to try the fish fry. Thank you for turning our night into a great evening after we had a rough day. We will definitely be back. Be sure to check out their Thanksgiving Buffet!

New favorite place! Went for brunch (available weekends). Veggie skillet and veggie omelet were amazing. Everything was fresh and hot! Prices very reasonable for quality and quantity of food (under $50 for 2 meals, 1 bloody mary, 1 mimosa, 1 tea). Server Kelly was great! Look forward to trying the Friday fish fry. Highly recommend Mayor’s!

Nice restaurant in a historic building. Had the Diane medallions and the sauce was very flavorful. The arancini were crispy outside and tasted almost like a spinach dip inside. Pasta portions were very large for the price and the Cajun sauce was very flavorful. Overall I would definitely come back to try other items! Staff was very friendly.

My first visit to Mayor’s Restaurant was so good that I had to come back again—this time for a classic Wisconsin fish fry. The fish did not disappoint: perfectly flaky on the inside with a crunchy exterior, fresh and full of great flavor without being greasy. I also enjoyed a cup of broccoli cheese soup, which was absolutely delicious—rich, creamy and comforting on this cold Wisconsin evening. To round out the meal, the old-fashioned was spot on. It’s a true Wisconsin staple, and Mayor’s definitely gets it right. The service was very good and quick, which made the experience even better. Overall, another excellent experience and a place I’d gladly return to again.