Matty's Pizzeria

31 July 2025 This Pizzeria was definitely a surprise. We dropped in here for a salad order because we just got to town. The place was really busy with online and phone orders. They took our order (two salads) saying it would be about 20 minutes. After a 30 minute wait I asked about my order they said it would be another 10 minutes. We were waiting outside they said they'd bring out our order. After 15 minutes a lady yells out the door that we could come in and pick up our order. HOW RUDE! Yes, the salads were very good, but the service really is messed up. 3 August 2025 We decided to try Matty's Pizzeria again but this time we called in our order on the phone for pizza then gave a time for pickup. In this case the pizza was ready to go and the in store service was fantastic! That was defin

1st timer trying Matty's. Called in for a large pep, fresh mushroom, and garlic pie. We'll be back again soon. The pizza was absolutely amazing. From the dough and crust to the perfect cook time and perfect amount of toppings. Their sauce (We ordered their regular sauce) was really good. Next time I'm ordering extra sauce because it was so pleasing. Keep up the good work Matty's! I HIGHLY recommend giving this establishment a try.

Too much going on there. Stuff all over the counter. Subs were expensive and both had a funny taste. We could not quite describe? (Pepper?old oil in dressing?) Dining area needs to be cleaned out, old and dusty. Garbage cans outside were overflowing, open and smelled awful walking up to the place. Maybe a smaller menu will help them with quality food. Wasn’t good.

A quiet little pizzeria, waited a couple minutes for someone to come out front to help us. Took my order and disappeared in the back for 4 or 5 minutes and came back with slices. The 2 slices i had were decent, hot and tasted pretty fresh but nothing spectacular.

Had traveled out of state for work to clear the power lines, absolutely the best food I’ve had in this area, nothing like a friendly welcome and an amazing food.