Matteo's of Roslyn

It takes a special skill to make basic Italian-American food underwhelming and bland but this place does that well. If you don’t know good food, you might like it here. Two people in our party asked our waiter about 6 times if the bolognese had any dairy in it and asked for dairy free recommendations, he assured us it absolutely had no dairy as I’m allergic. It literally had visible cheese all over it. He also recommended the branzino, which was fine but pretty flavorless, small, and didn’t taste fresh. After 30 minutes I was able to get his attention (he never checked in with us even when I told another server that I was told the bolognese was dairy free…) and asked if he can give me some bolognese in a bowl or something without cheese so I don’t have to leave the place hungry and I said

We had such a great dinner here of a party of 16. lol. Thank you to Brian for making everything go perfectly for our mom’s birthday! The food was amazing and the staffing was great!! Definitely will be going back again!!

Thank you so much, Matteo's team and Brian, for making another company dinner truly amazing! Brian was beyond welcoming and accommodating during our service. The level of hospitality last night was incredible--every time we visit, we're greeted with such a warm welcome! The food was outstanding, and the service was exceptional. Brian, you truly did an amazing job leading the team. We love dining at Matteo's and look forward to visiting again in the near future. If you're looking for a place to host any event, this is THE SPOT! You won't leave disappointed. Thank you so much, Brian and the entire Matteo's team! Liz & Entire North Bay Cadillac GMC family.

We went to Matteos in Roslyn on a Tuesday evening to meet our friends visiting from Florida. The host and wait staff were very friendly and attentive. The food was delicious. The pasta dishes were yummy and the sole oreganata was also good. Since our friends were visiting from out of town, we may have over stayed our welcome, however, we never felt like we were being rushed out.

Matteo’s has been a staple in Roslyn for Idk 20 years now. Food is consistently fantastic and comes out lightning quick but still delicious, service is professional, warm and not overwhelming. Manager Brian is beyond pleasant and you can tell he genuinely takes being of service seriously and professionally. Definitely a go-to if visiting or you just moved to the area.