Mattenga's Pizzeria 46 HW New Braunfels

Coworkers all hyped this place up pretty good, HAD to try it. REALLY good pizza. Online options were quite large, figured I'd walk in and order in case I had questions. Ordered a straight up pepperoni w half of it adding jalapeños. Pizza was awesome, the peppers were actually quite spicy (a rare treat for me as I LOVE it HOT) Will definitely order online next time, although waiting wasn't too long. Gonna try some of their specialty pizzas next time I think, you can apparently order specialty pizzas by the half also... Two different specialty pizzas half/half even... Sounds pretty cool to me.! Definitely coming back.! Inside is kinda smaller, mostly a take out pizza place, but they have a few tables inside and picnic tables outside. Pepsi products for drinks is the only thing I can eve

This was hands down the best pizza I’ve had in a while! The pizza itself was absolutely delicious, and the homemade ranch took it to another level. I tried both the jalapeño ranch and the garlic ranch, and honestly, I couldn’t decide which one was better—both were amazing. Dipping the pizza in them made every bite even more flavorful. On top of that, the service was great—very welcoming and friendly, which made the experience even better. Incredible pizza, delicious house-made ranch, and excellent service. Five stars all the way! 🍕

This was my first time trying this place out. I ordered the Honey Bexar and Garlic Cheesy Bread. The pizza is amazing, I love when places actually put on TOPPINGS everywhere on the pizza. The Garlic Cheesy Bread was okay. The only items I didn't like were the sauces. The to go marinara is frozen, and the ranch is just salad dressing ranch. If the marinara had been warm or at least no frozen and ranch homemade that would've bumped this up to 5 stars. Staff was very kind and attentive.

Great pizza (we had a margarita special) and good rolls ( a bit on small end). Beware there is an online order fee (was about 5%) for us. People were friendly. Order ahead order was ready within 10 minutes of the scheduled time.

I ordered Mattenga’s for the first time and had a great experience. The online ordering page was easy to navigate, and the turnaround time was quick. The customer service at the restaurant was terrific. Everyone was so kind and friendly. We ordered a 16” pepperoni and supreme pizza. Both were so good! I like that the crust is not too thick or too thin. It is just right in my opinion.