Maria's Pizza Milltown

We tried a local pizza restaurant who appeared on Barstool Pizza Review. Maria’s in Milltown, NJ. Noted for their bar pie. The thin crust favorite. This restaurant has their own parking lot which was impressive in size. This was a nice touch. The entrance to the doorway had a few steps to take with a special sign warning not to hold on to the shaky loose railing. The interior was typical of a pizza establishment. Staff of 6 were busy and we were greeted at the counter. Ordered the “Bar Pie” and took about 15 minutes. The pie arrived hot and steamy. The pie looked inviting. The pie was thin and had a good taste. Could have used more cheese. The crust was super thin with a nice underside crust. The slice had structure and no flop. Having tasted a few thin crust bar pies Maria’’s had on

Still the best pizza around. I grew up in NJ and came here when they opened in the 1980s. Slices are still huge, delicious and for a great price. Staff is super friendly. Just excellent!

I recently visited Maria’s Pizza in Milltown, New Jersey, and I have to say—it was hands down the best pizza I’ve ever had. The crust was perfectly baked, the sauce was rich and flavorful, and the cheese had that perfect melt that makes every bite unforgettable. You can tell they use quality ingredients and put real care into every pie they make. On top of the incredible food, the service was amazing. The staff was welcoming, attentive, and made the whole experience feel warm and inviting. It’s rare to find a place where both the food and the service are top-notch, but Maria’s delivers on both fronts. If you’re anywhere near Milltown, I highly recommend stopping by Maria’s Pizza. Whether you’re local or just passing through, it’s absolutely worth the visit—you won’t be disappointed especia

Maria’s is the go to pizzeria in milltown. Good service. Good food beyond pizza too! Wings are good. Italian dishes like chicken francese are great options for that person in your house that doesnt like pizza too. Maria’s had a small area for dining in. Mostly for grabbing a slice in the go.

Consistently good. I've enjoyed almost every variety of pie they have (maybe pass on the hot dog pie and get an Italian hot dog instead which is one of the better ones around here imo). Also, they have their own delivery people which, for someone like me who is tired of Doordash markup, makes them that much more appealing.