Margarita's Pizzeria

While in town for a family trip, we decided to skip cooking and ordered pizza from Margarita's. It was really good. When I went to pick up our order, the owners were incredibly friendly and struck up a great conversation while I waited for the pizzas to be ready. Their sauce was a 10/10 – highly recommend.

I went to Penn State for 6-7 years (don't judge me) the previous decade. Margarita's was my go-to! Embarrassingly, I really don't have much to say about their pizza, I've actually never tried it. HOWEVER - Their baked Italian Sub is top-3 on this planet! Maybe #1 (I've tried a lot). Perfectly toasted with right amount of dressing with premium meat/cheese. It's also ginormous so come hungry. I'd actually recommend not eating at all the day before you're planning to try one. I literally cannot order another menu item because I enjoy it so much and don't want to deviate from the script. They're not open on weekends, so I usually will take at least one Friday off a year during PSU football season to come up and get one - it's THAT important. This may be burying the lede, but Juan and Marga

Great food and friendly staff. Unfortunately since they are not open on weekends I rarely get to enjoy their pizza. When I worked downtown I ate lunch there at least once a week

Some of the best pizza I’ve had in State College. The owners were nice and seemed like they were close with their regular customers. I had plenty of leftovers for the next few days. There is a $10 minimum for credit card so just be aware of that.

People here are super nice. Had a great conversation with one of the owners about her Italiy trip. Pizza was excellent. Solid slice. Sauce very good. Great Place. I would go again next time in Happy Valley.