Main Street Creamery & Cafe

Hands down the best ice cream in all of Connecticut Idk how they do it. But the ice cream is absolutely perfect. The perfect level of sweetness, the perfect texture, the perfect amount of mix ins. And the menu is perfect. They have the exact right amount of regular flavors and seasonal/rotating flavors to make you keep coming back. I LOVE their flight option, for just $2-3 per scoop you can get 4 scoops, me and my husband always get 2 scoops each this way and get to try a bunch of flavors at once I love the location in old whethersfield it's always nice to stroll the area with ice cream in hand Every time I have come here, even in the summertime when they're super busy and the line is stretched out the door the employees are always kind and helpful and yet quick and efficient. Don't le

Gave the maple walnut ice cream a shot — not bad, but waaay too many crushed walnuts. I’m team chunky nuts, please! The real winner? The raspberry sorbet. My girls devoured it. Total hit — highly recommend! 🍧🍓

First time trying their ice cream and can’t complain at all! Ordered 4 flights with different flavors. We had about 10 different flavor ice creams, a couple of each of the cookies, brownies, and each flavor macaroons. Money was well spent! Delicious ice creams and baked goods. The staff was very pleasant and friendly as well; and the store was clean.

Ice cream is ok. However, the staff seemed more concerned with rushing through orders than providing quality service. Customers are told to "slide over" to make room for other customers, and the girl working there had a terrible attitude when bringing my order to the table. It was clear that she was not happy to be there, and her negative energy made the experience even worse. If you're looking for a real gelato experience with great service, I recommend walking a few yards further to Noci. They offer a 360-degree superior experience. Save yourself the disappointment.

Absolutely wonderful ice cream. Large selection. This business is hugely popular and the lines are long. In spite of that, the service is quick and accommodating. Parking is difficult - on-street only and not easy to find a place. But it's worth the trouble