Magic Fountain

One of the best ice cream spots in New Jersey. What I love most is that you really taste the authentic flavors in every scoop. Definitely try the Peanut Butter Cup and Butter Pecan—they’re incredible!

I wish I could gate keep this place but because it is SO good I want everyone to know!! It’s already widely popular. Usually you go to an ice cream place and just get toppings on top but MF clearly puts them in while doing soft serve so it’s equally spread. It’s the best! Their soft serve is delicious. I really loved the Smores flavor ice cream as well. I also recommend the brownie sundae! I don’t normally order warm/hot things that come in plastic but it’s just so delicious. You get a lot for your money here and it’s homemade. Totally worth the wait because lines get long here! Even in the rain there’s lines.

I don't understand the ratings this ice cream shop has received based on our own visit. The ice cream was super soft and marshmallowy, which is a mortal sin in my book. I had vanilla chip and coconut on a chocolate cone, and truly regretted eating it. I actually would have preferred to have never visited, and I really, really love ice cream. My son was equally unimpressed by his Oreo cream and cookie dough. My wife thought her mint chip and maple walnut were passable, at least, but she's also the least discriminating of our group. If you think I'm just "that guy" who is never satisfied in reviews, I encourage you to look at the other 30 or so ice cream reviews I have...

If you miss the old school ice cream store, you have to head over to Magic Fountain! They have the favorites like cookie ice cream sandwiches, ice cream cakes but also slushees, cool cones options and so much more. It’s cash only in you’re ordering in person . Fast service too

Great spot in Summit, been here forever. Always a line but it moves pretty fast and they have a huge selection of items. Good to have the wait to decide! Especially like the banana ice cream with Nutella - sugar bomb but super tasty!