Maggie Mays

Excellent no BS Irish bar and restaurant with fantastic food and a cozy atmosphere. The bartender Gary is a friendly guy and the service is top notch. I got the dinner special which was the fireman’s meatloaf. It was one of the better meatloafs I’ve had; super moist and flavorful and the portion was enormous for the price. Mashed potatoes were creamy and green beans were fresh. The french onion soup here is perfect. Also, the Caesar salad is fresh, crisp and tossed with proper homemade Caesar dressing and excellent garlic croutons… plus it’s topped with slices of fresh shaved Parmesan that are so good they stand on their own. The salad was huge and was only $8.99. Always pleasant music playing too. This place is a gem and a retreat from the crazy world.

I absolutely LOVE this restaurant! The staff is attentive and well mannered. Their food is delicious and affordable. The inside of the restaurant is beautiful as well! Such a calm and peaceful setting especially at night time. Their lobster ravioli special is fantastic and their chicken fingers and honey mustard sauce appetizer tastes delicious! Everything is always clean! Will definitely keep coming back!

Maggie Mays is a wonderful local staple. It is an Irish pub with delicious food that reminds you of home. I highly recommend trying the daily specials, they never disappoint. Our waitress recommended the ribs and they were excellent. She was so kind and attentive. If you are looking for good food in a cozy atmosphere, this is your spot.

A-MAY-ZING - loved it, we had the ribs, zucchini wafers, porkchop and the lamb chops, everything was delicious. Service was also…you guessed it, amazing! Definitely coming back often to try the rest of this menu.

The go to of Bayside, the last Irish pub. Cozy, huge portions, friendly locals. A classic bar.