Macy's Place Pizzeria

I ordered the Beer Battered Fish Fry last night and unfortunately it didn’t live up to expectations. This is Western New York, where the fish fry competition is strong, so the bar is pretty high. The filet itself looked like a good size at first, but it ended up being mostly batter — probably 70–75% — with a very thin piece of fish inside. Once I peeled some of the excess batter away, the portion of actual fish was much smaller than it appeared. The meal was also supposed to come with bread and butter, but that was missing from my order so I can’t comment on that. I skipped the fries since the dinner includes coleslaw, potato salad, and pasta salad, but each of those came in very small containers (about the size of a Five Guys ketchup cup). Had I known the portions were that small, I pr

I heard from a few people that they had good pizza. I was nervous because of the Google reviews being poor. But, on DoorDash the reviews are better. I thankfully had a great experience. I ordered a personal pizza with three types of veggies on top. Everything from the dough, to the sauce, and to the seasonings on top was very yummy. I look forward to ordering from here again. And the price was more than affordable, which is great in this day and age.

Ordered a large Dope boy pizza for around $30 and had it delivered by DoorDash. The pizza arrived burnt to a crisp (see the photos). It was not edible at all. I called Macy's and they did nothing..said that they could not issue a refund and that I had to go through DoorDash because I bought it through there. I asked them how it's DoorDash's fault for them burning the entire pizza to a crisp, and they said it doesn't matter and that they can't give me a refund. Unacceptable.

We ordered a small chicken finger pizza and 20 wings (garlic parm) on Uber Eats, and they provided a 20% off promo code. It was only around $40! Great deal! Even for takeout, the wings were a good temperature and still crispy. The pizza was perfectly cooked with huge sliced chicken fingers as toppings. I would definitely say this place is a notch better than Franco’s! We will definitely order again.

Tried out Macy’s Place in Kenmore after only having positive experiences with the Cheektowaga location and left pretty disappointed. The personal pan pizza tasted good, but that’s about the only thing they got right. It looked messy, wasn’t sliced properly, and felt like no care was put into how it was served. Customer service was pretty bad. She told us it would be a 45-minute wait, but it was ready in about 10–15 minutes and no one even let us know. It just sat there while we waited. Also, if you get a pre made single slice, don’t expect it to be warm they don’t reheat them, just hand it to you room temp without saying a word. I only went to this location because it’s next to Fattey’s where I was hanging out, but I’ll stick to the Cheektowaga spot from now on. This one didn’t live up to