Luigi's Pizzeria of Mineola

What a Hidden Gem! Discovered this Amazing Pizza Restaurant after making a wrong turn and I am SO glad i did. Great vibe, GREAT pizza , super clean and modern he had and so many different food choices. If pizza could have a candy store this would be it! The owner was super friendly and genuine! They have a reward system with every purchase and I can’t wait to come back with the kids! It will easily become our new Italian family restaurant! MUST try everything! Nice parking lot and super nice staff. NYC pizzerias for the most part can be “not so friendly” to 1st time customers! Tend to stick to locals. They are Usually friendly after your a known repeat customer BUT not here. Owner treated me with respect and kindness and even threw in some garlic knots on the house and i felt wel

I tried Luigi’s Pizza for the first time and overall had a good experience. The staff was very friendly and the atmosphere was clean and welcoming. I had two slices. The buffalo chicken slice was excellent—great flavor, plenty of chicken, and I liked having the choice of blue cheese or ranch at no extra charge. I also tried the Grandma Vodka Sicilian. I’m very particular about vodka sauce, and while I understand everyone has different tastes, this one wasn’t for me, it had a different taste . Because the vodka slice is something I really look for in a pizzeria, that’s ultimately why I couldn’t give a full five stars. That said, Luigi’s definitely makes good pizza, and I’ll be back to try other slices on the menu.

I got the most expensive side salad for lunch. Called to ask if there was a mistake and the girl was not helpful and insisted I made an ordering mistake. Moving forward we’ll only order from Rosa’s. The side salad wasn’t even good.

My first visit and take-out: $21.39 on March 4, 2026, about 6:00 pm. Hard to compare with Stella's Ristorante in Floral Park and Gino's in Williston Park, restaurants that have retired over the last year, and they were second to none in this area. The Penne and so-called marinara tasted like canned sauce, not whole tomatoes seasoned. I asked for extra Garlic, and it was raw canned garlic, like you buy at a grocery market from a jar. One tiny piece of bread. Before I ordered, I spoke to Louis to get an idea of the dinners, since this was my first time visiting Luigi's. This is not the quality I expected. I am Sicilian, and this is not the standard for me. Joe

My husband and I ordered delivery. My husband had stromboli & mozz sticks and I had shrimp scampi over broccoli rabe. I had to call and ask for the manager. I spoke to Luis and had to tell him how amazing their food is. The shrimp was cooked to perfection and so flavorful. My husband loved the stromboli and mozz sticks. We’ve ordered from there multiple times. Pizza, pasta etc. Their food NEVER disappoints. Always fresh, hot and delicious. Luigi’s is amazing and the staff is so friendly. Picking up, delivery or eating in? I HIGHLY recommend. 5 stars all around!!