Luigi's Pizza & Restaurant

My office had an outing at the Jersey Shore Arts Center in Neptune. It was a murder mystery show where you could bring your own food and drink. I asked an employee there to recommend a nice pizza place that I could order from. He suggested Luigi’s. Our outing was for Sunday so I went in the day before to look at the menu, meet with someone to place the order and make arrangements for pick up time. Sebastiano greeted me and showed me the catering menu and helped me pick out different pizzas, salads, desserts etc. Great, all set. He’s super friendly. I’ll see you tomorrow at 4:15 for pick up. Wait, you’re not open tomorrow? What? Noooooo… Sebastiano says they’re not open on Sundays. I ask him if he knows of any other places near by. I have one day to arrange this menu and get this food

A Slice of Heaven If you’re a true pizza lover, this place is a must-try. The crust strikes that perfect balance—crispy on the outside, soft and airy inside. The sauce tastes homemade, with just the right hint of herbs and sweetness, and the cheese melts beautifully over every bite. What really stood out were the toppings: fresh, flavorful, and perfectly portioned so every slice felt indulgent without being heavy. You can taste the care that goes into every pizza that leaves the oven. Whether you’re dining in or taking it to go, this spot delivers comfort and quality in every slice. A definite five-star experience for pizza enthusiasts!

After leaving a previous five star review , I am following up with a second one star review after a horrendous experience. Before leaving this review , I contacted the restaurant by email and was ignored. A recently ordered a large chicken caesar salad and calamari. I\nHad been given a ten percent discount code which I applied , and it did not work no big deal. When the order was delivered, the driver was so rude.That I called the restaurant to complain about him. Then\nWhen I went to consume my food , I found the chicken caesar salad to be old stale and literally not edible.

This place is fire. Always fresh, big and delicious. Ingredients look super fresh. Certain specialty slices are huge/thick and plenty to choose from. Glass shelves/casings are very clean and the pizza moves. Its doesn't sit stagnet all day. Very busy, great Italian vibe with the 🎶 music. Probably the coziest pizzeria I've been to. Definitely recommend this hands down for quick eats with big flavors.

It's rare these days that you walk away from a misunderstanding with an improved view of someone. I've been a patron of Luigi's for several years. Without a doubt they have the best lunch slices in the area. Last week I ordered catering for a golf outing party where I was hosting 30 guests. I asked a friend to pick up the catering from Luigi's and he called me from the restaurant with the bad news that they had the order written down for one week later. Obviously this would have been a disaster for me. 30 golfers and no food! Rather than debate who was in the wrong or right regarding the order date. The Luigi's staff immediately recommended that they could make the food ASAP and deliver it to my home in Bradley Beach. This is what I consider outstanding service. Thank you Luigi's