Lucy Blue Pizza OTR

Lucy Blue, a hidden gem among the local eateries, offers a delightful dining experience that goes beyond the typical chain restaurants we often encounter during our travels. Situated in a quiet corner, the restaurant exudes a simple yet clean and bright ambiance, creating an inviting atmosphere. The pizza arrived promptly, cooked to perfection, and the crust was simply amazing! As food enthusiasts, we were particularly impressed by the added herbs that enhanced the flavor, transforming the crust into a meal in itself! Jim, the friendly owner, shared captivating family memories and fascinating insights into the city’s history, making our visit even more memorable. The conversation flowed effortlessly, and the pizza was nothing short of fabulous—one of the best we’ve had during our numerou

Came down with my husband from Dayton for a short 4 day trip and ate the last night. The pizza was the best we ever had. It was the Hawaiian pizza can’t wait to try the other ones if we ever come back to town.

Ate at Lucy Blue today and had such a wonderful experience! Not only was the pizza delicious, but I met the owner, Jim, who was super nice and welcoming! Definitely recommend if you’re in the area.

Our company catered lucy blue for a large event and they did amazing!!! We catered through ezCater but I will definitely be booking straight through them for a better deal and to allow them to get more of the profit. The owner, Jim, is so kind and helpful. He stopped by our work early in the morning to make sure he knew where to go and set things up and even came back with a "thank you" cookie. I will definitely be using them again and their physical location is so beautiful! The buffalo pizza was hands down my favorite. As a blue cheese hate I was THRILLED to finally get a slice of buffalo pizza with no blue cheese!

In town for a visit with family performing at the Shakespeare theater. Service- ordered online, Valentine’s Day(busy). Food received from uber driver not concealed with any type of restraints such as tape, staples or reciept attached. Order- 16” Supreme pizza cold, bland and soggy. Garden salad, with extra Italian dressing was not in the order. Never delivered. Italian sub sandwich,decent. Tried to reach out to address the issue, hard to make contact. Phoned and emailed. Would not recommend.