Lighthouse Bagels

Honestly, these are the best bagel breakfast sandwiches my wife and I have ever had—and we’ve been coming here since 2001. Truly authentic NY bagels in a variety of flavors. Sandwich ingredients are prepared on the spot, and it’s always consistent. A true home run.

A good place for quick breakfast. There’s bagels are fresh and their breakfast sandwiches are plenty. On a weekend there’s always going to be a line so plan ahead. Their service is quick so doesn’t matter the crowd. The bagels are nice and fresh with a variety of cream cheese options. The coffee cake was not that great, just a load of sugar in a cake.

This native New Yorker had to try the NY bagel shop when in Corolla. I had saw a TikTok featuring this place weeks ago and knew I wanted to try it. So after catching the sunrise we headed over to the bagel shop around 7am and there was already a line outside. That’s a good sign in my book! The line was long but it moved swiftly. Lots of staff on deck with pleasant attitudes greeting and helping the customers. I was waited on by a man training another young man. He was friendly and efficient and obviously invested in the training of the individual. Now to the important part of the visit. The bagels! Fresh and delicious and absolutely reminiscent of what I’d find back home in Long Island, NY. The cream cheese is homemade and delicious and they really are generous with the smear…. Which if yo

Bagels were good, but the service was not the best. One of the staff members was not the nicest when we were selecting a 12 pack of bagels. Inside the restaurant was not the cleanest either. Food was great though.

I highly recommend a trip to lighthouse bagels. The service is quick, although the shop does get busy quickly, go early if you can. Service is also very friendly and can make ordering fun if you have a good attitude with them. Overall the prices are very good at about $2.50 a bagel when ordered by the bakers dozen. Sandwiches and cinnamon rolls are more experience but still a fair price in my opinion. Check them out for breakfast. They have a good amount of outdoor seating too.