Kaye's Cookie House

I first tried Matthew’s cookies at the Wire Park Farmers Market and WOW—they were unbelievably delicious! When I started putting together Christmas gift boxes for our business partners, I knew I had to reach out to him about catering options. From the very first message, Matthew was fantastic to work with. He was incredibly responsive, took my project idea and tight deadline in stride, and went above and beyond to make it happen. He even delivered everything earlier than expected and kept me updated at every step. The cookies were a huge hit and the entire experience was truly a pleasure. If you’re looking to support a talented local small business AND enjoy some of the best cookies you’ll ever taste—Matthew is your guy. Highly, highly recommended!

We ordered a few hundred cookies for gift boxes and they were all expertly made. We ordered a few for ourselves, too, and they were delicious :)

Every one of these cookies I've tried have been amazing. The sea salt on the Imposter and Classic cookies is so tasty. I think my current favorite is the Sweetheart though - the buttercream icing is fluffy perfection. Will definitely order from here again

Absolutely delicious cookies- some of the best I’ve ever had! Each one was perfectly baked with amazing flavor and texture. Beyond the treats, the owner is incredibly kind and welcoming. It’s clear he puts a lot of heart into his work. I love supporting local businesses, especially when they’re run by people who truly care about their community. Don’t miss a chance to stop by and treat yourself!

We ordered the variety pack, and got several of each kind. They were all delicious, but I have to say, the Cinnamon Son was on a whole other level. I don't normally use this term, but it was the Perfect cookie. I will definitely be ordering from here again. Matthew even met me close to my house to deliver the cookies personally. If I could give 6 stars I would. EVERYONE should experience the transcendent joy of these cookies. Thank you Matthew!!!!!!!!!