Judi’s Ice Cream

2 stars is being generous. Has the potential to be a great spot, but the customer service is lacking as well as the ice cream. I got the pumpkin pie twisty, and it was very “meh”. Pumpkin pie is Sysco brand, I had to ask for allergy reasons, and the maple creemee barely tastes like maple. My friend got a peanut butter pie milkshake, and it was more like peanut flavored milk. Portions are generous but the quality is lacking. Do not recommend, if you’re looking for ice cream local to Williston I recommend Island Cafe Homemade Ice cream in Williston, VT.

I got the chocolate chip cookie sandwich. It was pretty big. Other than that, it didn’t taste much different than the prepackaged ice creams. The girl in the front was also rude. They need some training on how to speak to customers without an attitude.

Come here for the vibes and friends. The hard ice cream is just Gifford’s, so nothing special. You could very easily buy and make at home for considerably less, which I want to emphasize again, you come here for the vibes and company.

Great ice cream. Just be careful of the portion size. I ordered a single scoop and it was a 2-3 scoop. I also ordered 2 kids scoops and they were more like a 1-2 scoops :-) The only minor thing I would say is that the line was a little long but likely due to the great ice cream but they could use a few more staff.

I've been here 5 times. Love love the soft serve Maple. PRICY, however, it's worth it. Great place to take your wife for a date night treat after dinner. Line can be long during desert time in the evening. Customer service was good. Love the vibe and location. Plenty of parking. Bring friends to talk with while waiting in line. It's worth the wait. My wife enjoys the hard ice cream even though it's outsourced... It's a treat and experience, and we don't have to do any dishes. Perfect for a date night. Will come again.