Yellow Mustard Subs and Sandwiches

The subs taste great!! They make them however you want... toasted, not toasted, variety of veggies & meats, or not, panini's, extra's... you name it! And their app makes ordering ahead easy - with whatever selections you want, and you earn bonus points to boot. Excellent experience! It's becoming our favorite sub shop....

I got the Pastrami on rye sandwich, but with sourdough bread instead. Great cheese pull, cheese was super stringy. Sourdough was crunchy and earthy. The meat was well seasoned and they give you plenty of meat on the sandwich. Very filling. The mustard was nice and slightly tangy. Would highly recommend.

A bit mixed reactions to this shop. There was only one guy working and he did a great job, absolutely working his hardest! Other hand really felt like the owner let him down. A lady spent maybe 20-30 minutes trying to use a gift card and the worker was having issues with the machine accepting it; we could hear the situation going on then him calling the owner to try and resolve it and the owner didn't pick up. I felt so bad for the worker!! He made our sandwiches fantastically (we tried a range of custom panini, the Bob panini, and the Southwest panini--all perfect and delicious). Will definitely visit again.

5 Star experience! Amazing French Dip sub with Au Jus on the side. The BEST I've ever had. Family run local business with friendly workers and a casual and clean sandwich shop! REPEAT for sure! Thanks Yellow Mustard for bringing your amazing menu to little old Williston Vermont! :)

Outstanding sandwich shop! Jeff is a sandwich master and pleasant as can be. Fantastic service, indeed! When you add the above superb qualities to what are very reasonably priced selections, what more can you say? Highly recommended.