Johnny G’s Famous Pizza & Tomato Pies

Ordered a traditional and sicilian tomato pie. The crust was a big let down, flavorless and no chew. Sauce was okay and bake was good. Inside there is a counter with vape stuff, toys, skillz games, boxes… basically a hodgepodge with mediocre tomato pie.

Pizza was amazing!! Very different then your average pizza shop…..crust was amazing & flaky sauce was amazing not too heavy….just right! They even waited for me way after they were closed!

I love their pizza. It’s different than others in the area, thin crust, sweet sauce, swirl cheese! The sandwiches that I’ve tried have all been tasty and fresh with nice options. I have had a few problems with ordering (some of my family’s favorite pizzas are odd) but they ALWAYS correct any errors quickly and politely. For instance, they realized that there was an error with my last pickup order before I even got home, and they delivered the correct item 10 minutes later. These guys work hard to make a delicious product. It’s my new favorite takeout pizza!

I've been buying cars from the same salesman Larry Gilman and he stopped at Johnny Gs on 2nd Street Pike and bought the best hot roast pork and roast beef sandwiches I have ever eaten and the pizza was incredible

I absolutely hate writing bad reviews 😢 We ordered a pepperoni pizza which wasn’t terrible, but I also got a thin crust margarita pizza and it was awful. The sauce tasted like ragu, the dough was ehhh and there was hardly any fresh mozzarella and basil. I have been meaning to check this place out and disappointed we did!