Johnnie's New York Pizzeria

Nice pizza but there is no ambiance in the seating area.

Really enjoy this spot. Pizza is a little pricey, but every time I’ve ordered, pizza is fresh, very tasty, and very well sliced, which all matter the most. Great staff as well. I love their varieties of pizzas as well. I recommend the Sweet and Spicy Sausage and also the New York White pizzas. Very happy they are on the west side.

My preference is for a standard parlor type pizza, rather than the small wood-fired artisan types. Therefore my rating is appropriate in context, this is an exceptionally good pizza for its type. Note also, like many parlors, this is called "New York", but it's not that thin, fold-over type with sparse cheese, this is much more substantial, and more to my taste. Good solid crust, tasty and chewy down to the end, the sauce a little sweet, which is fine, and perfect cheese, not globs of it that end up pulling off the slice, just right to the bite. The cost is a bit more than a comparable Domino's down the street, and for that you get a heck of a lot better pizza (and a lot less salt). For MdR, or maybe anyplace these days, the price is quite reasonable. I recommend the large, even if y

Ordered pizza and chicken which were both fab. The pizza was amazing and the wings cooked to perfection. We were even offered a free pizza. Staff were fantastic.

Unfortunately, because they don't let you order directly from them but must go thru a separate app, wirh added expense of course, even for pick-up orders, I'll not be going to Johnny's anymore. Sad. 😔