Joes Pizza Restaurant (Shirley NY)

Ordered some wings to go with the pizza. Absolutely disgusting looks like week old wings. Would not recommend. Garlic knots did not taste fresh or even taste like garlic just old leftover pizza dough. Pizza was ok at best

Let's start with the Pizza - the bread/crust is so doughy it's hard to process. Sauce is eh, but then again there is no good pizza in the area. Now to the delivery, I ordered from UBER Eats, pizza came in cold. I ordered Zeppolis and got two sodas instead. When I called the pizzeria the guy said, "I was trying to hook you up". If I wanted soda I would have ordered it, but dude what about calling UBER EATS (or getting on the App) and saying it's not available. Or why have it on the app menu? How hard is it to throw in some dough in the deep fryer and add sugar?

My friends and I ordered 3 pies from this establishment today for lunch and I can’t tell you how disappointed I was with the product I received! They put the pies in a small pizza box which in turn folded the pizza! I have never in my life received a pie like the way I received these pizza pies today! And what’s worse the worker said that this was normal and that they do this kind of thing all the time! All I can say is that I didn’t spend $56 for folded pizza! I will NEVER order from here EVER again!

I went late (around 7pm). There were no other customers. A specialty slice is $5 even. I got a chicken Parmigiano slice. I used the bathroom (customers only with a 😡) and there was no toilet paper, so I used the paper towels. There was a tip jar (which also had the 😡, strangely enough). The pizza was pretty good-crispy with a lot of cheese and good amount of chicken. I would have liked more sauce, though. I can't say if the sauce was good or not because there wasn't really enough to taste it. Overall, I'd try this place again.

Great food, prices and customer service. A winning combo for me! Convenient location as well.