Jimmy's Jersey Street Cafe

As a traveler, it's rare to find a spot where both the food and service are so good that you want to come back the very next day, but that's exactly how we felt about Jimmy's. Tucked away in a quiet neighborhood with plenty of parking, this place delivers. The staff was welcoming, the atmosphere relaxed, and every dish we tried felt thoughtfully made. Indoor and outdoor seating options make it even more inviting. If you're looking for quality Italian food that feels like money well spent, Jimmy’s is it. Must try the Banana Fosters for dessert.

We had an absolutely fantastic Valentine's Day dinner last night! The special 5 course menu was incredible -- I loved the tomato bisque soup and the salad was perfection. We both got the gnocchi as our mains and it was AMAZING. A wonderful tres leches cake topped it off. Great, great service as well. Thanks to the staff for making it such a special occasion.

We spent a lovely Valentines evening at Jimmy's and their food really hit the mark 💘. The restaurant was very busy and the did have a special Valentines menu which had a fair amount of selections. We got to pick an appetizer, soup, salad, main and dessert. We started with crab cakes and they were lovely. Light crispiness on the outside and perfectly cooked and seasoned. Our soups were also delicious! I had a butternut squash soup which was creamy and rich. We each had a steak for our mains and they were cooked with care and very tasty. My wife's lobster was also very good. One minor gripe was that she was supposed to get a risotto with her order and got veggies instead but she enjoyed them and we were pretty full at this point anyways. For the dessert we got to pick several mini desserts

I’ve dined at Jimmy’s with a large group (over 30) twice in the past two years, and it’s been fantastic each time! The food is delicious, elevated, and perfectly portioned. I’ve especially enjoyed the linguine with clam sauce and steak. The staff have handled our large group with flawless efficiency and kindness. If you’re looking for a fun experience, I highly recommend trying the bananas foster.

Jimmy's is a true neighborhood gem. The food is fresh and delicious, service is friendly and the atmosphere is quaint and tastefully outstanding. Highly recommend for lunch, brunch and dinner! (We've tried all three and have never been disappointed.)