Jersey Mike's Subs

This location is consistently the worst Jersey Mike’s that I’ve been to. The amount of meat they put on a $20 sandwich is a joke. The Wentzville location gives 2 to 3x the meat that this location does. This is the 3rd and final time I will be going here. Being cheap will cost this location in the long run.

I had the BEST experience at the brand-new Jersey Mike’s in Lake St. Louis on opening day (August 20, 2025)! From the moment I walked in, the staff made me feel so welcome. Everyone was so friendly, upbeat, and clearly excited to be there, which made the energy amazing! Special shoutout to Eric and Kayden, who were awesome, and the young lady with the pink and purple hair—she was so sweet and helpful. Honestly, every single team member went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect. The food was fresh and delicious (of course!), but what really stood out was the exceptional service and positive vibes. I will always come to this location whenever I’m in the area. Great job, team—you made opening day unforgettable!

Typically the food is great... if you can get it....but there are multiple times when the menu is shut down for online ordering hours before their closing time. Such as tonight. At 630pm... when they are supposed to be open until 9...forced to go in because they shut off their online menu..again... the entire restaurant is cleaned, everything is put away, only a few wheat breads available for a limited topping sandwich because everything is put away 2.5 hours before closing..... again..this happens regularly. Just another lake st louis chain that starts strong for a month then immediately drops off to absolutely abysmal quality and service. Given the absurd prices of this place you would think they would at least fully service people until closing... absolutely ridiculous. We should get a

1st time that my hubby and I ate here. It was great! Tried their gluten free bread, very soft and great taste. The staff working were very helpful and kind with us newbies! We live like 3 minutes away and will definitely be back.

This location is off to a Terrible start . Manager is rude . Had a sandwich remade that didn't have any oil on and got an oil and vinegar soaked mess . If you cant handle customers go do something else . 1st time and last time . I'll stick to the O'Fallon location.