Il Paradiso Pizza & Restaurant

Usually amazing pizza, long time customer my favorite spot. Disappointed in my last visit. Overcooked pizza, and got charged for a large but received a medium.

Our thanks to Allen and team for their exceptional service. Our Senior Community ordered some pizzas for a New Year's Day Event. The veggie pizza was outstanding and the cheese and pepperoni ones were delicious too. They even gifted us a stromboli due for the inconvenience of time constraints. In today's economy, kindness and great customer service stands out. Thank you very much! May 2026 bring you prosperous life, health and business!

I ordered the platter of 50 chicken wings which it was supposed to be half barbecue and half garlic Parmesan. Went to go pick up. Had to wait an hour. When I got home come to find out all the chicken wings were mild spicy. They were so dry it didn’t have any flavor. They put the Garlic oil in a cup!. Like what the hell is that? I was so disappointed. I didn’t even bother to call I was so mad. Guess I will not be ordering chicken wings from there ever.

I had a great lunch today. I went in for a slice and a can of soda and the lovely server suggested that I get the lunch special (two slices and a fountain soda). The pizza was classically delicious and the fountain soda was really refreshing. After lunch I went for a walk on airport road which parallels the Shawangunk Ridge.

Got the cheese deep dish. On the phone I was told it was about 14" so I wasn't sure if it was worth paying more than the 16" pizza. It was absolutely more food and was amazing. Normally I eat most of a 16" pizza in one sitting but was full after 2 slices of this stuff. Each slice weighed ¾lb and was about 1.5" thick. Wife got calzone and loved that too. Pizza definitely didn't taste like average ingredients. And the owner responds "thank you" to a bunch of reviews, which shows me they care. We had about 15 pizza places to choose from while staying at the Yogi Bear campground 20 min away and I'm glad we picked this place.