Idyllwild Pizza Company

Food was genuinely delicious. Ordered the antipasta salad and the Tahquitz Supreme. The crust on that pizza, the sprinkles of sea salt and crunch on the outside and softness on the inside, was so so good. I usually don't eat my crust, but here I could eat it alone.

My Calzone was soooo melty, meaty, cheesy, and warm. The cooler mountain nights had me shivering a bit, and this warmed me up nicely. The personal pizza ended up being $30 (yikes inflation). They had some arcade games, claw machines, and other vending machines in the back. They looked like fun, but I don’t carry change. Overall it’s a pretty standard pizza place with that arcade air of nostalgia from back in the day when I’d go for pizza and game nights with my family at the local pizzeria. I’ll visit again.

The pizza is good. The pasta is average, but I definitely didn't like the wings; they're baked, not fried, and there's more skin than chicken, so you can imagine what it's like to eat them 🤢 The staff are friendly and the place is comfortable. But I would NEVER eat those wings again.

This pizza place is great. Delicious pizza, friendly staff and always trying their best to get things moving. On super busy days be ready to wait for your pizza for about 40 minutes or an hour wich they well let you know when you order but for us is worth the wait. This is our place to eat when we to Idyllwild, play in the snow, get a beer and eat Delicious pizza.

Great pizza joint. No waiting tables just easy-going. Really tasty and thoughtfully made. Salad was legit too. If they had used a Pizza Stone or steel for the crunchy firm base it would’ve been perfect. Kid friendly. Oh and Military Discount offered. Let’s go!