Holy Cow Ice Cream Cafe

We stopped here on our anniversary trip! Highly recommend the earl gray. It’s unique and sweet. Cozy up on a bench and enjoy.

Mary was so sweet holding down the fort. With a huge line, she managed make the experience for us and our dog memorable while absolutely hustling. Ice cream was fab town too!

Very nice little ice cream stand! The waffle cones are made fresh in front of you, and the ice cream tastes good and quality. They have quite a few options, and offer something for everyone to enjoy (even vegans)! The staff were super friendly and helpful as well. The only thing I’d say needs improvement is the bottoms of the waffle cones - they had holes and immediately began leaking all over. Maybe a specific plastic waffle cone holder would help? Other than that, it was really great. We would definitely recommend trying the Coffee, Cinnamon Churro Dough, Toasted S’mores, Wild Blueberry Pie & Vegan Strawberry Stracciatella.

Plenty of flavors. Good prices. Decent portions. Friendly service. Tasty ice cream. Across from a park where you can sit at benches or picnic tables with views of the water.

Hands down the best ice cream you can get at Salem. They've a wide variety of flavors and they're all delicious. I absolutely love their key lime pie, jackpot and eazy peazy flavors. The ice cream is reasonably priced and you get a lot of ice cream for that price. Kylie, Cassandra and Lilly were friendly and offered us fantastic service 💯