Holy Cow Ice Cream Cafe

Zach was scooper awesome! He let us try a bunch of flavors and listened to our questions and gave good recommendations. Love that we can get great ice cream in the off season- and so many wickedly good seasonal flavors too!

Great ice cream shop. Went in and was a little overwhelmed by the choices. Alex helped me choose a flavor. He explained that the flavors with the baby’s faces were the owners kids, so I chose one of those, Cecelian cookie. It was really good, reminded me of my grandmothers Italian cookies, not overly sweet. The location is great. Right on the corner in a happening shopping area. They also make their own waffle cones fresh to order. They even had cool branded napkins. I do wish they had cookies or brownies, but I think they just focus on the ice cream.

Wow! Soooo many unique flavors! There was a pistachio baklava and a ritz cracker toffee and a strawberry cheesecake butter cake! I wish they did flights because I’d order five flavors at once (I sample three. The banana foster and the pumpkin chocolate were amazing). I just…I wanted to try them all!!! It was also very fairly priced. $6.99 for two flavors!

The flavors of the ice cream here are so special and so tasty. Andrew, who helped us at the store, was very friendly. He gave us several samples to try and we loved all of them. It was so hard for us to make the decision on which flavors to choose....Then we ended up having 9 flavors among three people 😜 We will definitely be back!

Great flavors. Really enjoyed the combo of Lunch Lady and Corner Piece. Waffle cones were great and fresh. Riley and Maddie were very efficient and made sure we had everything we needed.