Harpoon Eddie's

This place was absolutely packed. Really relaxed vibe in here. The waitresses sat me next to a bunch of college kids. They were loud and boisterous. 🙂💯🫶 But once they got their food. They chilled out and the vibe got even better. The waitresses were all hustling and working very hard. Very pleasant and kind. If your not a local, just be prepared for all the motorcycles when you enter. Don't be intimidated. You would be surprised how kind bikers can actually be. There is a full bar inside and outside as well. The views of the beach both inside and outside are amazing!!! Food was excellent! Rice was a bit undercooked but they immediately brought out some new rice and apologized for the inconvenience. So kudos for customer service!

Very fun place with good food and right on the beach. Indoor and outdoor seating with live music outside. Utica Club on draft with various other choices. Beach access. When the indoor seating is full it can get very loud. But the beach view is delightful. Friendly staff and fair prices.

We went here looking for good food and a great atmosphere. The place is right on the water, they have indoor and outdoor seating. There is a big bar outside and there was a live band. We got sat right away (party of 6) and then the server took a long time to come to us. I think she got double sat but we waited at least 10 mins to be greeted and get waters. We ordered and they messed up our drink order. They have an extensive drink menu but the drinks are on the weaker side, the drink prices aren’t listed. We got the clams $18 for 12 and they were very sandy which was disappointing. Two people got burgers and they were very good, they come with chips and you cannot up charge to add fries. We wanted fries and had to get a whole basket of them. I got the fish tacos with grilled fish and the f

Writing this review from June, 2025, we had gotten takeout from this place. The food was NOT WORTH THE VERY EXPENSIVE PRICE!!! We spent $200 without knowing for 4 PEOPLE. They charged us $20 for water which is crazy. The shrimp cocktail was warm and was $15 for a couple of small pieces of shrimp that was supposed to be jumbo. Mac n cheese was $28 and was cold and disgusting. We got side salads and the greens were soggy and brown. It took 30 minutes to come out and the appeal of the area was seedy. A HORRIBLE BIRTHDAY DINNER FOR OUR SON!! We couldn't be more disappointed with this spot.

Harpoon Eddie's at 611 Park Avenue, Sylvan Beach, N.Y., offers an exceptional dining experience with a variety of delicious dishes and a charming atmosphere. The personal pizzas, especially the Margarita pizza, are the perfect size with a perfect crust and a delightful balance of cheese and pineapple. The garlic parmesan fries are truly the best fries I've ever had. They have a satisfying crunch on the outside, are soft on the inside, and are perfectly flavored with parmesan, making them a must-try. The gigantic loaded french fry platter was a fantastic appetizer for our group of seven, providing a great start to our meal. Harpoon Eddie's riggies are also a highlight. The light sauce adheres perfectly to the rigatoni, offering a mild yet delicious flavor. The accompanying side salad with