Gourmet Bake Shop

Peet's coffee in Dunkin & Starbucks heartland!! That drew us in for a breakfast bite. Apart from coffee, we settled for toasted, buttered croissant, cheese puff, coffee cake. All spot on. Latter two delicately sweetened, in keeping with times. We'd have preferred coffee cake to be little more moist. The place attracted a steady stream of regulars; all helped by Ali & Fiona with friendly alacrity (even helped us by heating milk for coffee). Seemed like they bake breads in small batches. Also had an assortment of cookies, cupcakes, mousse, pastries, tarts, eclairs, cakes and, of course, New York Cheesecake. In an increasingly online world, they need to move away from a generic, nondescript website (that just does not do justice to ready for takeaway goodies); to a more available-here-and-no

I needed a cake for my god son’s first birthday. I knew nothing about cakes and I wasn’t sure what kind to get. I gave them my idea and they brought it to life ! Everyone loved it. It was amazing !!!

My favorite bakery in New Hyde Park. The girls at the counter are always very nice. Some of my favorites include their blackout cake, fruit tarts, and black and white cookies. They also have some good Napoleon and chocolate PB tarts. Very good variety at decent prices. Year later review - still amazing, well worth the price. They are now open on Mondays. I don't live in New Hyde Park anymore but I still try to make it here. I highly recommend this bakery.

I ordered my mom’s 60th birthday cake over the phone and i am very satisfied with everything. The baker is so talented. The service is wonderful. And the cake tasted great! This is my family’s go to bakery and I have never had a complaint. Also, always love their cookies!

I tried 5 different things. They were all good but the jelly filled donut stole the show! That jelly has levels to it. The flavor starts out nice but then it surprisingly kicks into another gear. The danish was almost as good as the jelly donut. It’s good in its own way. Definitely will return for the both of those. I also tried an apple turnover, banana walnut muffin, as well as a raisin bread. The pastry part of all of them was good and tasty. I didn’t try it yet but they have sugar free options. Overall, everything was good. If you’re in the area give them a try.