Goodnight’s Prime Steak + Spirits

Went there for our 2 year dating anniversary. From the moment we walked in the door it was about us. We were made to feel special and that felt good. The food was out of this world delicious. Each course came at the right pace as to not overwhelm us. Our main course couldn't have been more perfect. Although we can't afford to go more often, we will definitely be back when we can.

Crab cakes were very good. Entrees were cold/ room temp. My husband's ribeye was mediocre. My beef filet was full of sinew and the cut was terrible. It was beyond rare. The sides came in skillets Brussel sprouts, and loaded potato puree. I would expect them to be hot but they weren't even warm. We ordered their apple skillet which was also cold. The service was good, decore was beautiful, and the drinks were good. Definitely not the Wow factor you would expect for a $430 dollar dinner before tip.

We always bring our out of town guests here. Best steaks ever, hands down. Their rolls are also a must.Technique is obvious in every bite. You can feel the leadership in the kitchen. Everything is always seamless. My husband always orders a flight of salt for everyone (to see which one they prefer) We recommend making a reservation. We always get a lovely card signed by staff with a metal horseshoe. It's a little out of our way (coming from San Francisco or Hidden Valley Lake) but worth the beautiful drive.

Dinner at Goodnights – A Night to Remember Our family dinner at Goodnights was nothing short of spectacular. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with an atmosphere full of charm and soul, thanks to the smooth, live jazz music that set the perfect tone for the evening. The highlight of the meal? The steak – perfectly cooked, juicy, and bursting with flavor. It was easily one of the best we’ve had on our trip. And then came the mashed potatoes – creamy, buttery, and so delicious they deserve their own spotlight. Honestly, they might just be the best mashed potatoes we've ever tasted! What truly elevated the experience, though, were the incredible servers. Friendly, attentive, and genuinely welcoming, they made us feel right at home. Out of all the places we’ve visited, these were h

Our server was very attentive - the atmosphere was everything you would expect from a nice steakhouse. And though my husband really enjoyed his steak (it appeared nicely prepared and presented) the rest of the food was not great. The Parker house rolls - meh at best. The roasted squash - undercooked. My tuna main dish was weird - nothing like the menu description - and oily and tasteless. Even the baked potato - which is a staple item for a good steakhouse - not great. Everything kind of just felt oily. Dinner for two (including tip) with one beer and one cocktail was just under $400. Even at half the price or one quarter the price - I would not go back. So many other better options in Healdsburg.