Goodfella's Pizza LLC

We just tried their pizza for the first time a few weeks back. We really like it. Great value for the price. Check their website for good specials. I believe they have them for every day of the week. We are definitely going to be buying from them again (and have been since our first visit). I highly recommend you give them a try.

This is the only place I'll order pizza in wabash! Between the fresh ingredients and the way they make their crust and twist it underneath instead of over the top just makes it so much better. You'll know what I mean if you e had some good fellas ❤️

We ordered a 3 topping pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms and green OLIVES. We got green PEPPERS instead. My husband does not like green peppers. He called to asked that they remake the pizza. Manager Linsey refused to make it right. Would only offer $5 off our next order. She said they were too busy to do it. She said they had too many orders ahead of us and they couldn't do it besides they had already taken care of us. I really don't feel we were taken care of when we didn't get what we ordered. Poor management!!

Ordered gluten free crust - she said it came as 12” and charged for a 12” plus $3.50 extra for the GF crust. The pizza smelled horrible when I got to my car - I opened it up and it was burnt! I took it home and measured it and was a little under 9” including the burnt crust. When I cut that off it was an 8” pizza. Crust was burnt on the edges and not cooked Underneath. Like eating soggy bread. The pricing online was not the same as they charged me. I also “treated” myself to their GF chocolate cake. It was about 3” - was not cooked - was fudgy throughout. The order before tip was over $28.00. I never place reviews but this was ridiculous. I would not recommend ordering gluten free anything here’s. The GF spinach crust pizza I got the last time was also soggy. I will not be going back.

Absolutely outstanding food. Best pasta I’ve ever had, best pizza sauce and by far the best breadsticks/cheesy garlic bread. My husband and I have found our new favorite spot to eat. Great food, great people, great place!