Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill-BBQ

We ordered takeout from Goodfellas New York Pizza and overall had a really good experience. The food traveled well and everything held up nicely by the time we got it home. The pizza was definitely the highlight. The crust had great integrity and held up really well under all the cheese without getting soggy, which I always appreciate. It was flavorful and exactly what you want from a good takeout pizza. We also tried the Philly cheesesteak, which was pretty good. The meat could have used a little more seasoning, but it was still enjoyable and loaded with toppings. My father ordered the burger and thought it was slightly overcooked for his liking and had a bit too much mustard, but he still said it was good and ate the whole thing. The eggplant parm served over spaghetti wasn’t my favor

The best restaurant within a 20-mile radius. All the dishes are delicious, the ambiance, the interior and exterior decor, the very friendly and attentive staff, and the excellent service and attention. If I could give it more than 5 stars, I would give it more than 10. I definitely recommend it.

Great pizza as always! Glad to have some real NY pizza back in town. Huge 18 inch and consistent every time. Love the new location easy to find and nice and clean. Great service at the counter/dining area

Their pizzas absolutely delicious nothing can compare!!🙌

Had a first time visit here today, and wasn’t disappointed. The Reuben and the Cuban sandwiches were fabulous!