GOODFELLA'S Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta Restaurant - McCordsville

McCordsville, IN · Pizza restaurant

Rating
4.3/5
★★★★☆ 4.3
Reviews
20
Rank in McCordsville
#5
of 27 restaurants
City Percentile
73%
rating percentile
Address
GOODFELLA'S Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta Restaurant - McCordsville, 9641 Olio Rd, McCordsville, IN 46055
Phone
(317) 336-6666
Website
www.goodfellasindy.com
Status
Closed · Opens 11 AM

GOODFELLA'S Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta Restaurant - McCordsville is a restaurant located in McCordsville, IN. It is one of 27 restaurants listed in McCordsville. Its 4.3-star rating matches the McCordsville city average of 4.2 stars. It ranks #5 among McCordsville restaurants by combined rating and review volume. There are 10 photos associated with this location.

About GOODFELLA'S Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta Restaurant - McCordsville

At Goodfella's, we pride ourselves on preparing a delicious meal for every customer, every time. Our ingredients are fresh, and our staff is friendly and courteous. For your convenience, we offer dine-in, pickup and delivery service.

Hours

Saturday11 AM–10 PM
Sunday11 AM–9 PM
Monday4 PM–9 PM
Tuesday4 PM–9 PM
Wednesday4 PM–9 PM
Thursday11 AM–9 PM
Friday11 AM–10 PM

Customer Reviews

★★★★★ 5.0 Tracy Streeter · Jun 2025

It's an excellent option for Italian food. The brick-oven pizzas and pasta dishes are delicious. But my wife had the shrimp scampi and wasn't keen on its vinegary taste. The chicken wrap was very appetizing.

★★★☆☆ 3.0 Andrew Mancebo · Dec 2024

We ordered the traditional Pepperoni and a traditional Margherita. The Pepperoni was ok just too much cheese not enough sauce. The Margherita was better than the Pepp. I was impressed at their brick oven but even more impressed that the Pizza didn't taste like it was even in there. No char, no undercarriage, what a shame. The service was nice, good vibes inside. Overall ok pizza, the Mrs and I are glad we went, just don't think we'll be back 🫤

★★★★★ 5.0 Jeremiah · Jul 2024

Wife and I have been here 2x now. Kind of a date night when the kids aren't home for dinner. The place is cozy, as we grabbed the same table in the bar area on both visits. Awesome calamari, we got it for an app both times. The first visit, I tried the lasagna and loved it. The second visit, I ordered a supreme pizza. We got a couple desserts to-go last time. Service was perfect both times. We will be back, and try something new here soon. If you are in the area, and wanna try something new... try it out, the menu has tons of options. Plenty to choose from... but most folks seemed to be ordering their brick oven pizzas. 5 stars

★★★★★ 5.0 Allie Mcbeal · Jan 2025

The layout of this restaurant is very nice. It is a lot larger on the inside than it looks on the outside. The wine selection is just to die for. My husband, a friend and I sat at the bar last night. Bethany was our server. She informed plus of the half price wine night (Tuesday) and made meal suggestions. My husband had the Bianca pizza which I tasted and was the show stopper! I had the veal which was great but I ate too much fresh bread and oil so I couldn’t finish. My friend had the rigatoni which was also amazing. We will definitely return.

★★★★☆ 4.0 Mark Rumney · May 2023

We definitely had a fun visit on a busy Friday night visiting Goodfellas, not to confused with a similarly named pizza place. As I had to do, went straight at the veal parmigiana. Nice portions, sauce was fresh and cutlet, tasty for a patty mix. Don’t get me wrong, I enjoy them but nothing compares to the actual cut of veal. Had a wonderful cocktail from the menu after some planning and substituting since a key item was out. What deserves it own 5 stars to me was the Carrozza. It takes your idea of friend mozzarella to another level. It’s been that long since I saw it on menu and highly recommend it.

Accessibility & Amenities

✓ Outdoor Seating ✓ No Contact Delivery ✓ Delivery ✓ Onsite Services ✓ Takeout ✓ Dine In ✓ Fast Service ✓ Great Beer Selection ✓ Great Cocktails ✓ Great Wine List ✓ Serves Local Specialty ✓ Lunch ✓ Dinner ✓ Solo Dining ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Entrance ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot

Services

Pizza restaurant

Top Restaurants in McCordsville

NameRatingReviews
Los Agaves★★★★★ 4.520 reviews
The Grill★★★★☆ 4.420 reviews
Maple McCordsville★★★★☆ 4.420 reviews
Noble Roman's Craft Pizza & Pub★★★★☆ 4.420 reviews
BIGGBY COFFEE★★★★★ 5.06 reviews
West Coast Sourdough - McCordsville★★★★★ 5.02 reviews
Megumi of McCordsville★★★★★ 4.80 reviews
Papa Johns Pizza★★★☆☆ 3.40 reviews
McDonald's★★★☆☆ 3.20 reviews
Starbucks★★★☆☆ 3.10 reviews

This listing is informational. Contact the business directly to verify credentials, services, and availability.