George's Pizzeria

Overall Score: 6.1/10 – A unique spot with good food, a charmingly old interior, and a welcoming atmosphere that makes up for its smaller size and worn appearance. Atmosphere and Service: 6.3/10 – The building has an old, almost run-down feel that adds a unique character to the dining experience. The brick interior is especially cool and offsets the smaller dine-in and outdoor areas. The restaurant appears clean despite its aged appearance, and the staff is friendly and hardworking. Food arrived hot and fresh, showing a dedication to quality. NY Cheese Pizza: 6.2/10 – A very good pizza with decent quality and a fair price. The taste was satisfying and closely aligned with a New York-style pizza. While the crust had a nice crispness, the undercarriage was a bit too soft, which slightly de

This visit was disappointing compared to our past experiences. The Alfredo sauce was very thin, more like soup than the creamy sauce we expected. We also noticed the pizza sauce has changed, and the flavor was not the same as before. The atmosphere felt different from previous visits, and the staff appeared inexperienced. When we asked questions about the menu, we weren’t able to get clear answers. Additionally, our waitress spent time on her phone, and our pizza sat at the window for a while before being served. This place used to be special for my wife and me as part of our date nights, so this experience was especially disappointing. I truly hope things improve, as we’ve enjoyed this restaurant in the past.

I travel 200 days a year and have eaten pizza all over the country (and Canada). This is hands down the best pizza outside of New York. I don’t have an office in Wake Forest, but I’m thinking of adding one just to be close to this slice. Era squisito!!

I catered three large trays for a party of 40 people and could not have been more pleased. The food was excellent and enjoyed by everyone. I placed the order in person two weeks in advance and the entire process went smoothly. The pricing was outstanding for the number of people served and I could not find comparable value anywhere else.

Great food. Great small and quaint atmosphere. Service was exceptional. My wife and I found our new local pizza spot. Give Stu a raise! He was working hard and super friendly. He gave excellent recommendations that tasted wonderful. Definitely recommend.