Gelato Envy

Gelatin Envy is a delightful spot that offers a refreshingly clean and well-maintained environment. From the moment you step in, the atmosphere is inviting and pristine, making for a comfortable experience. ​While the selection of flavors might be limited, every option we tried was a winner—the gelato is genuinely high-quality and tastes excellent. They focus on doing a few flavors very well, which is often preferable to a large, overwhelming, and mediocre selection. ​Beyond the signature gelato, Gelatin Envy offers a nice variety of other treats, including Sundaes and various Drinks. This makes it a great spot whether you're craving a simple scoop or something more elaborate. ​Overall Impression: ​This is a nice place to have an ice cream (or gelato!). It's a great choice if you prioritiz

Wow! Was expecting to love the gelato here but was still surprised how smooth and creamy it was. Even better than the reviews said. Flavors were so fresh and the store was super clean. Owner was there, and so friendly and even offered us complementary hot chocolate. We’d been to gelato shops in Italy and this is at the very top. People who live nearby are lucky to have this treat nearby.

There’s this awesome gelato spot in the Denville-Rockaway area where they make fresh gelato every day and offer a wide range of flavors. Their signature one is called “Every Flavor,” and they always have other tempting options too. Every day, they post the flavor of the day on their Instagram. I’ve been trying to get my hands on pistachio or orange, but by the time I get there, it’s always sold out. Even this time, I missed out again. I thought I’d at least get the guava flavor, but that was gone too! So, I ended up settling for a random pick—either pineapple or hazelnut chocolate. It was good, no doubt, but still not what I was craving. And so…the wait for my favorite flavor continues!

Took my kids here to try gelato and the flavors were delicious. I really liked that they used real mini spoons versus the small plastic spoons for samples to reduce plastic waste. I tried the fluffer-nutter and honey-comb caramel flavors and both were incredible. Gelato was super smooth and flavorful, highly recommend giving them a try.

Visited for the first time and the Gelato was good. But the portion sizes left me a bit wanting. I've never gotten such a small size of Gelato from any other place. It was like two mini scoops for child. They don't use normal size ice cream scoops. I was very confused when i got it.